Mary Belle, what were you thinking (A poem about my great-great aunt)

Mary Belle, what were you thinking (A poem about my great-great aunt)

Mary Belle, Mary Belle,
what were you thinking?

Auburn-haired lass
peripatetic sprite
one of a kind
one of a kind

First daughter
first daughter that survived
apple of your mother’s eye
apple of your mother’s eye

Named for her
named for your mother Mary
and called beautiful, belle
and called beautiful, belle

Mary Belle, Mary Belle,
what were you thinking?

Birthed in Vermont
alone among your siblings
natural-born citizen
natural-born citizen

The one true American
in a family of Scots
not of the homeland
not of the homeland

Did you know you were different
did you feel out of place
going your own way
going your own way?

Mary Belle, Mary Belle,
what were you thinking?

One brother a doctor
another a lawyer
and you a rebel
and you a rebel

Eloped at fifteen
with a forty-two-year-old neighbor
broke your mother’s heart
broke your mother’s heart

Stepmother to six
birthmother to six more
disavowing your childhood
disavowing your childhood

Mary Belle, Mary Belle,
what were you thinking?

Brothers and parents to Michigan
you stayed in Vermont
severed ties
severed ties

Now widowed at forty-eight
estranged mother dead too
who will comfort you
who will comfort you?

Did you know you were different
did you feel out of place
choosing to leave
choosing to leave?

Mary Belle, Mary Belle,
what are you thinking?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *